Academy Award Nomination Highlights Challenges Immigrant Families Face

Perhaps the biggest surprise Oscar nomination on Tuesday was Demián Bichir in the best actor category for his portrayal of a Mexican undocumented immigrant.

In the film “A Better Life,” Bichir plays Carlos Galindo, a single father and gardener in Los Angeles struggling to build a brighter future for his American-born teen-aged son Luis. Carlos works long hours, hoping to save money to move to a neighborhood with a better school, so he isn’t around much to parent his son. Luis is losing interest in school and begins to skip classes and hang around gang members.

The movie traces the pursuit of the American dream, and shows how difficult it can be to obtain. It also addresses the emotional drama that unfolds when undocumented immigrant parents are deported and their children are left behind in the United States. This is a very timely issue since deportations reached the highest level in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement history in fiscal year 2011.

Like the characters Carlos and Luis, many immigrants live in “mixed-status” families. Researchers at  the Pew Hispanic Center estimate that about 9 million people are in families that include at least one undocumented immigrant adult and at least one American-born child. The center estimates that the number of children with at least one undocumented parent has doubled since 2000.

As reporters, our goal should not just be to write about policy or test scores. Placing a human face on issues is also important. Admittedly, immigration is a tough topic to write about when so many immigrants are afraid to have their names printed in the newspaper.

How does a young person cope when their parent is deported? And when a parent is deported, how is it decided whether the children should remain in the United States or leave? If they stay, what is the impact on their emotional state and schooling?

I watched the movie just last weekend. Be forewarned, it’s a tearjerker.

One thought on “Academy Award Nomination Highlights Challenges Immigrant Families Face

  1. I couldn’t agree with you more, Katherine. What a surprise performance this man gave us. I will definitely be rooting for this Oscar worthy performance. However, while the film and Bichir did an excellent job portraying the day-to-day life of an undocumented worker in Southern California, I personally felt the film could have done more to show just a little more of the post-deportation drama within a family. I feel this could have been attained if Luis, the son wasn’t such a troubled youth so detached from his father. In fact, I certainly got the impression that Luis was embarrassed of his father. While this type of father-son relationship may be common, I feel in a different scenario (where the father and son are very close) the movie could have touched more on the human-side. To see Luis mature throughout the movie was refreshing. However, had Luis had a more loving relationship with his father from the get-go, this movie could have really tugged at the emotional heart strings of seeing a family break apart. And I believe that type of positive and nurturing father-son relationship is just as common in society today. But to go back to Bichir’s role, truly magnificent!

Leave a Reply to Rudy Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s